- Jesse Anspaugh – 2nd Team Academic All-League (1999)
- Mark Baxter – Honorable Mention All-League (1998)
- Jack Belmonte – 2nd Team Academic All-Star (2016)
- Nick Belmonte – 2nd Team Academic All-Star (2016), Honorable Mention Academic All-Star (2017), Honorable Mention All-League (2018)
- Kayla Bennett – 1st Team Academic All-Star (2020)
- Josh Boone – 1st Team Academic All-League (1999)
- Joe Bordas – Honorable Mention Academic All-Star (2020)
- Kevin Bovair – 2nd Team Academic All-Star (2016), 2nd Team All-League (2017), 2nd Team Academic All-Star (2017), Honorable Mention All-League (2018)
- Dan Brockman – 2nd Team Academic All-League (2001), 1st Team Academic All-League (2002)
- Chris Brown – 2nd Team All League (2002)
- John Burkle – 1st Team Academic All-League (1998)
- Thomas Bush – Honorable Mention All-League (2020), 2nd Team Academic All-Star (2020)
- Braden Cox – Honorable Mention All-League (2020), 1st Team Academic All-Star (2020)
- Carson Cox – Honorable Mention All-League (2020), 1st Team Academic All-Star (2020)
- Jason Culham – Honorable Mention All-League (2000), Honorable Mention (2001), 1st Team Academic All-League (2001), Honorable Mention (2002)
- Brian Daniels – 2nd Team Academic All-Star (2016)
- Steve Datkuliak – 1st Team Academic All-League (2000)
- Rick DeBorde – 2nd Team Academic All-League (2000), 1st Team Academic All-League (2001)
- Gram Doherty – 2nd Team Academic All-Star (2016), Honorable Mention All-League (2017), 1st Team Academic All-Star (2017), 1st Team All-League (2018), 1st Team Academic All-Star (2018)
- Brian Daniels – 1st Team All-League (2016)
- Joey Donahue – Honorable Mention Academic All-Star (2020)
- Ben Duford – 2nd Team Academic All-Star (2020)
- Joe Duford – Honorable Mention Academic All-Star (2017)
- Adrianne Ehrhart – 1st Team Academic All-League (2002)
- Marshal Enfeld – 2nd Team Academic All-Star (2017), 2nd Team Academic All-Star (2018)
- Alex Folga – 1st Team Academic All-Star (2017), 1st Team Academic All-Star (2018), 2nd Team All-League (2020), 1st Team Academic All-Star (2020)
- Mike Folino – Honorable Mention All-League (1999), 1st Team Academic All-League (1999), 2nd Team Academic All-League (2000), 1st Team Academic All-League (2001), Honorable Mention All-League (2002), 1st Team Academic All-League (2002)
- Ben Gartz – 1st Team All League (1998), 1st Team Academic All-League (1998)
- Ethan Green – 2nd Team All League (2016), 1st Team Academic All-Star (2016), 1st Team All League (2017), 1st Team Academic All-Star (2017)
- Cole Gutterman – Honorable Mention All-League (2017), 1st Team Academic All-Star (2017), 2nd Team All-League (2018), 1st Team Academic All-Star (2018), 1st Team All League (2020), 1st Team Academic All-Star (2020)
- Riley Hanson – Honorable Mention All-League (2020), 2nd Team Academic All-Star (2020)
- Helen Harrick – 1st Team Academic All-League (1999)
- John Haverland – Honorable Mention All-League (2001), 1st Team Academic All-League (2001), Honorable Mention All-League (2002), 1st Team Academic All-League (2002)
- Maggie Hergenrather – 1st Team Academic All-Star (2017), 1st Team Academic All-Star (2018)
- Matt Hess – Honorable Mention All-League (2000)
- Owen Huff – Honorable Mention Academic All-Star (2020)
- Johnny Ives – Honorable Mention All-League (2016), 2nd Team Academic All-Star (2016)
- Ben Jordan – 1st Team Academic All-League (1999)
- Derek Johnson – 1st Team Academic All-League (1999), Honorable Mention All-League (2000)
- Pete Johnson – 1st Team Academic All-League (2000)
- Reagan Johnson – 1st Team Academic All-Star (2018)
- Sean Kelley – 2nd Team Academic All-League (2001), 1st Team Academic All-League (2002)
- Adam Klawton – 1st Team Academic All-League (1998)
- Frankie Kosir – 1st Team Academic All-Star (2018)
- PJ Kosair – 1st Team Academic All-Star (2016), 1st Team All League (2017), 1st Team Academic All-Star (2017), 1st Team All-League (2018), 1st Team Academic All-Star (2018)
- Kevin McClure – Honorable Mention All-League (2002), 2nd Team Academic All-League (2002)
- Kris McClure – Honorable Mention All-League (1998), 1st Team All-League (2000)
- Faith Martin – 1st Team Academic All-Star (2017)
- Joe Martin – Honorable Mention Academic All-Star (2020)
- Nick Martin – 1st Team Academic All-Star (2016), 2nd Team All-League (2017), 1st Team Academic All-Star (2017)
- Matt Meier – 1st Team Academic All-League (1999), 2nd Team Academic All-League (2000)
- Michelle Meier – 1st Team Academic All-League (2001), 1st Team Academic All-League (2002)
- Mason Kikesch – 2nd Team All-League (2018)
- Layne Miller – 2nd Team Academic All-Star (2017)
- Matt Parker – Honorable Mention All-League (2000), 2nd Team Academic All-League (2000), 1st Team Academic All-League (2001), Honorable Mention (2002), 1st Team Academic All-League (2002)
- Chad Peacock – Honorable Mention All-League (2017), 1st Team All-League (2018)
- Nate Schievelbein – Honorable Mention All-League (2020)
- Jeff Shulman – 1st Team Academic All-League (1999)
- David Smith – 2nd Team Academic All-League (2002)
- Justin Tall – Honorable Mention All-League (1998)
- Sean Williams – 1st Team Academic All-League (2001), 1st Team Academic All-League (2002)
- Mara Williford – Honorable Mention Academic All-Star (2017)